I had an interesting discussion with one of my (many) liberal friends recently, and there's a couple of points that came out of our prol...
Friday, January 9, 2009
Friedman Op-Ed
Here's what I consider to be a balanced look at the latest Palestine Israel conflagration, from Tom Friedman writing for the New York Times. Comments anyone?
2 comments:
Anonymous
said...
I think Friedman is a Jew, but he does make an interesting argument. I can't understand those who have knee-jerk sympathy for Hamas, which is quite clearly a terrorist organization bent on destroying Israel (and also preventing more moderate voices in the Palestinian community from leading toward a solutions).
The bloodshed is a direct result of Hamas waging a tactics war against Israel, shooting rockets until they retaliate, and then hiding behind civilians in order to get coverage from CNN.
Shame on the Left for playing into this nonsense. There can be no progress until the moral distinction between Hamas and the state of Israel is made clear.
Anonymous, thanks for the comment. I agree with the substance of your remarks but take issue with the comment about Friedman being a "Jew". Whether or not this is true, it's hardly relevant to his position. No ad hominems please, and no racial slurs on this blog. But I do agree with the substance of your comments. It is indeed a shame that the Left can't seem to draw a clear moral distinction and has this "knee jerk" sympathy for all things against Israel, when it is quite obvious to moderates (and of course the political right) that a very clear moral distinction exists. I also agree with your ending comment, which is that we must begin with acknowledgement of the moral distinction, and then can make some progress. Getting the terrorist organization Hamas -- funded by Iran -- out of power so that the Palestinian people can have some brighter days ahead would seem to be the first step. Let's hope that Israel can accomplish this.
It's theory and "praxis," or in other words, practice. Thaxis is an ongoing discussion of bad and mythical theories that lead to bad practices. We tweak the future to flourish, by always questioning and exposing bad theory and its link to our current practice. The blog touches on any and all topics related to--what else?--theory and practice.
Update: In returning to thaxis years after actively posting, I'm more inclined to keep a journal of thoughts which may or may directly address a particular pain point, but will I hope converge on a picture of things that serves the basic purpose. In other words, read it to find out what I'm thinking about, and read it for discussion also of specific topics, as the case may be.
2 comments:
I think Friedman is a Jew, but he does make an interesting argument. I can't understand those who have knee-jerk sympathy for Hamas, which is quite clearly a terrorist organization bent on destroying Israel (and also preventing more moderate voices in the Palestinian community from leading toward a solutions).
The bloodshed is a direct result of Hamas waging a tactics war against Israel, shooting rockets until they retaliate, and then hiding behind civilians in order to get coverage from CNN.
Shame on the Left for playing into this nonsense. There can be no progress until the moral distinction between Hamas and the state of Israel is made clear.
Anonymous, thanks for the comment. I agree with the substance of your remarks but take issue with the comment about Friedman being a "Jew". Whether or not this is true, it's hardly relevant to his position. No ad hominems please, and no racial slurs on this blog. But I do agree with the substance of your comments. It is indeed a shame that the Left can't seem to draw a clear moral distinction and has this "knee jerk" sympathy for all things against Israel, when it is quite obvious to moderates (and of course the political right) that a very clear moral distinction exists. I also agree with your ending comment, which is that we must begin with acknowledgement of the moral distinction, and then can make some progress. Getting the terrorist organization Hamas -- funded by Iran -- out of power so that the Palestinian people can have some brighter days ahead would seem to be the first step. Let's hope that Israel can accomplish this.
Post a Comment